Index | Blog | Forum | Contributors | Contact Us
hificritic.com
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Forum
  • Subscriptions
  • Issues
    • Current Issue
    • Current Issue Excerpts
    • Back Issues >
      • 2021 - 2022
      • 2019 - 2020
      • 2017 - 2018
      • 2015 - 2016
      • 2014 - 2013
      • 2012 - 2011
      • 2010 - 2009
      • 2008 - 2007
    • Back Issue Excerpts >
      • 2022 Excerpts >
        • Vol 16 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 16 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 16 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2021 Excerpts >
        • Vol 15 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 15 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 15 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 15 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2020 Excerpts >
        • Vol 14 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 14 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 14 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 14 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2019 Excerpts >
        • Vol 13 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 13 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 13 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 13 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2018 Excerpts >
        • Vol 12 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 12 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 12 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 12 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2017 Excerpts >
        • Vol 11 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 11 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 11 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 11 No 1 Excerpts
      • 2016 Excerpts >
        • Vol 10 No 4 Excerpts
        • Vol 10 No 3 Excerpts
        • Vol 10 No 2 Excerpts
        • Vol 10 No 1 Excerpts
      • Excerpts 2007 - 2015
    • Sample Issue (Download)
    • Annual HIFICRITIC Indexes
  • Reviews
    • Hardware Reviews
    • Sound Classics
    • Review Classics
  • Recommendations
    • HIFICRITIC Awards
    • Colloms Sound Quality Ratings >
      • Ratings Explained
      • Digital Audio
      • Integrated Amplifiers
      • Power Amplifiers
      • Preamplifiers and Phono Stages
      • Loudspeaker Cables
      • Interconnect Cables
  • Feedback
    • Leave Feedback
    • Feedback 2009 to present >
      • Feedback 2015-2016
      • Feedback 2013-2014
      • Feedback 2011-2012
      • Feedback 2009-2010
    • Contact us

New Flagships From Martin Logan, ML

21/4/2016

0 Comments

 
Premiered At London Audio Specialist, KJ West One,  April 15-16 2016
​Audiophile products distributor Absolute Sounds ran a two day series of presentations at the prestigious West End audio store KJ West One, both for press and public. Absolute Sounds audio technology chief Pedro Jorge Luis has been keeping an eye on the more recent developments at ML now that ML Chief Audio Technologist Joe Voijko, a 20 year veteran of the company, has really got his teeth into high end hybrid moving coil /electrostatic loudspeaker design. Two important developments were brought to our attention, the recently introduced, part active Renaissance Series and new to the UK, the massive and purely passive Neolith flagship weighing nearly 400lb each, where most of this mass is down to the bass section!
Renaissance
There are four Renaissance systems in the pipeline with somewhat different sizes and powers, and here the ESL 15A was featured. These are part active, with room compensated dual 12 inch bass drivers, one front and one back, with 500W amplification for each, with on- board 24bit DSP processing for the bass, while they are also readied for Anthem room correction software. The first introduced ESL 15A is priced at £25,000 and claims 22Hz to 21kHz  +,- 3dB response. It has a high 92dB/W sensitivity and this suggests that these speakers are designed to play loud when needed, even to 110dB. New generation, higher performance electrostatic panels are fitted with improved step-up transformer. They also include:

‘PoweredForce Forward bass technology uses an advanced crossover topology with phase-timed woofers to minimize destructive reflected energy by virtually eliminating front-wall bass reflections’

This is an established and successful ML technology to better match the otherwise omnidirectional radiation from the bass to the inherent dipolar sound radiation from the ‘open’ electrostatic panels. In this series there will also be a ESL 10 at £10k and an ESL 12 at £15k. (Save for the Classic 9 passive). The technology and bass amplifier powers are the same, just the woofers and bass enclosures change size. 
Picture
ESL15A Renaissance
For this demo we had Constellation Inspiration amplification using a Brinkmann Bardo LP turntable with the Brinkmann 10.5 arm fitted with the new version of the Kiseki Blue moving coil. Here the fine sounding phono stage was the Trilogy 906e.  CD replay was by Metronome here ‘Le Player’  and this system also featured the latest Gen 5 cables from Transparent throughout.
 
Sound Quality  
Under both  difficult and unfamiliar room conditions , the Martin Logan ESL 15A showed prodigious bass for its size,  crisp and tuneful with enough dynamic ability to keep up with the low mass and super fast electrostatic mid treble. The sound was a clear step ahead for hybrid electrostatics in this sector while the potential for computer calibrated low frequency management takes care of bass matching to the room.

Martin Logan Neolith
The £75,000 Neolith was first shown at Munich 2014 and then at CES 2015 and 2016 but historic images or comments cannot prepare you for its sheer scale and presence in the solid. While other brands perhaps seemed to be crowding out the high end ML designs Pedro was determined to check out the Neolith at CES 2016 and as a result was strongly minded to recommend that a pair be delivered to the UK for assessment. The evident potential rapidly led to this special presentation at KJ, this demo run with huge Constellation Centaur II double mono amplification partnered by the Virgo 3 preamp. LP was assigned to a Techdas Airforce 3 turntable fitted with a Graham Elite arm, here swinging a Koetsu Azuli cartridge. Digital replay came from a Metronome Calypso player driving the matching Metronome Nausicaa DAC. All cables were Transparent Gen 5, these the next level up, as appropriate for this reference system listed at several hundred thousand pounds. 
Picture
Martin Logan Neolith demonstration at KJ West One
Neolith claims to play dynamically, and without apparent effort. From what I heard that must be true because the dynamics were effortless, and delivered with terrific punch and dramatic attack but not with any sense of strain or hardness. These electrostatic panels sounded the best yet, with hardly any inherent signature, and much less so than the equivalent signatures from most moving coil speakers. Voijko’s new toroidal approach to the vital signal transformer has had a big effect. With this new found scale and dynamic expression in the mid treble could the passive bass section keep up?  It most certainly did with the super power passive crossover to the dipolar bass array, here a 12 inch carbon fibre cone type at the front sealed enclosure with a phase controlled 15 inch alloy cone piston driver at the back.  Here the larger section is vented but at low Q factor and with adjustable acoustic projection to help match the upper panel. Maximum power input is over 1,000W which should give an equivalent (allowing for the non spherical directivity) maximum level at over 115dB at the listener location, quite extraordinary.  The bass matched the mid and treble for dynamics with body shakingly percussive and tuneful bass lines.

The structure is made of a beautifully lacquered and shaped high density structural grade of phenolic resin, while the new curvilinear high power electrostatic panel is 0.56 m wide and 1.2 m high. This diaphragm need hardly move at all over its frequency range and will have exceedingly low distortion as a result. There are three settings for bass level to suit location and room characteristics. If you need to know, crated they each measure 1 x 1 x 2 metres and weigh 273 Kg!
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Martin Colloms has a passion for audio and music and has written for many of the key hi-fi magazines worldwide.

    History

    January 2022
    June 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    December 2020
    September 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    December 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    November 2018
    October 2018
    May 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    December 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    November 2016
    October 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    March 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    March 2014
    November 2013
    September 2013
    July 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    October 2011
    September 2011
    August 2011
    April 2011
    March 2011
    November 2010

    Categories

    All
    Andrew Everard
    Book Review
    Chris Barber
    Concert
    Conference
    Exhibition
    Festival
    Hardware
    Hearing Loss
    HIFICRITIC Prices
    Launch Event
    Meeting
    Music Downloads
    Music Market
    New Issue
    News
    Paul Messenger
    Press Event
    Recordings
    Show
    Software
    Webinar/seminar
    Yasuko Everard

    RSS Feed

Articles

Features*
Reviews
Hardware 
Music *
Books *

Hardware Reviews**

Digital
Servers
Streamers
Music stores
DACs
CD players
Speakers
Stand mount
Floorstanding
Amplifiers
Power
Preamps
Integrated 
Phono preamps
Cables
Loudspeaker
Interconnect
Digital
Power


Analogue 
Turntables
Tonearms
Cartridges

Music Reviews*

Classical
Pop
Rock
Jazz
Collections

Classics

Sound Classics
Review Classics

Awards

HIFICRITIC Awards

Ratings

Colloms Sound Quality Ratings 
Digital audio
Integrated amplifiers
Power amplifiers
Preamplifiers
Loudspeaker cables
Interconnect cables

Reviews by Year

2020
2014
 
2013 
2012 
2011 
2010 
2009 
2008 
2007

Issues by Year

Current issue
2021 - 2022
2019 - 2020
2017 - 2018
2016 - 2015
2014 – 2013
2012 – 2011
2010 – 2009
2008 – 2007
Annual Indexes

Online Store

Subscriptions
Issues
Hardware Reviews

Contributors

Colin Anderson
Arthur Barton
Chris Binns
Chris Bryant
Harriet Bryant
Jay Clawson​

Martin Colloms
Peter Comeau
Stan Curtis

Greg Drygla​​
Ben Duncan
Andrew Everard
Tony Faulkner
Nigel Finn
Kevin Fiske
Chris Frankland​
Stephen N Harris
Steve Harris​
Andrew Harrison
Jose Victor Henrique​
Jon Honeyball
Keith Howard​
Jason Kennedy
Paul Messenger
Julian Musgrave​
Mark Prendergast
Malcolm Steward
Rafael Todes
Dr Charles Zeilig​

Feedback

What HIFICRITIC readers say
Leave your own feedback
Contact us
* Coming to hificritic.com in the future. **Over 150 more hardware reviews coming to hificritic.com soon. Tell us what you'd like to see. 
hificritic.com
© Copyright 2014-2020 HIFICRITIC Ltd All Rights Reserved | Terms of Use | Privacy and Cookies | Website by Paul Herzlich | Contact Us
Photo used under Creative Commons from wuestenigel
Index | Blog | Forum | Contributors | Contact Us
hificritic.com